Cigar Chief Reviews
Cigar Chief has an overall rating of 4.4 based on 105 reviews. Customer feedback on Cigar Chief is mixed: Cigar Chief reviewers highlight positive aspects like wide selection of cigars, competitive pricing, excellent customer service, fast shipping, which strongly appeal to cigar enthusiasts, casual smokers, gift buyers, collectors. However, Cigar Chief is often criticized for its limited international shipping options, occasional stock issues, website navigation challenges, higher prices on some premium brands.
105 reviews
5 Stars
21
4 Stars
3
3 Stars
8
2 Stars
0
1 Star
0
How would you rate Cigar Chief?
All Cigar Chief Reviews (105)
DavidPruden
May 22, 2026
"Quick and painless, thankfully"
I found what I needed fast, which was a relief because I don’t have much patience for digging through messy sites. The categories actually made sense, and checkout was straightforward enough, no weird loops, confusing menus, or anything that made me want to give up halfway through.
0
Reply
MITTENDORF
May 22, 2026
"Payment was easy, at least"
Checking out was painless and there were plenty of payment options, which I appreciated. that part went smoothly, though I was half expecting some annoying issue to pop up like it usually does.
0
Reply
WERNER
May 18, 2026
"Fast and Easy Order"
I ordered from Cigar Chief and was surprised by how quickly it showed up. The tracking was easy enough to follow, and the box arrived in good shape with no issues. Overall, it just felt like a smooth, hassle-free experience, and I felt good about ordering from them.
0
Reply
Edna-pacheco
April 19, 2026
"Order was right, but I felt a bit brushed off"
I ordered from cigarchief.com and everything showed up exactly how I picked it out. Right cigars, right count, no mix-ups or missing items, which was a relief because I always get a little nervous with online cigar orders. The packing was fine too. The only thing that threw me off was that when I had a question, the response felt kind of short and like I was being dismissed a bit. Still, the order itself went smoothly, so overall I’m happy and would probably order again
0
Reply
travishicks1622
April 17, 2026
"Mostly Fine, Despite the Magical Inventory"
I ordered a few sticks that were listed as in stock, because apparently I enjoy trusting website inventory. One ended up missing, but after I emailed, they swapped it out for something else. The rest of the order was fine and shipped without any drama. Overall, not bad, but keeping the inventory a little more up to date would be a wild and exciting innovation.
0
Reply
SPADA
April 12, 2026
"Good Finds, But Stock Moves Fast"
They’ve got some rare cigars that I don’t really see in a lot of other places, which is cool. Uh, just keep in mind the stock changes quickly because a few I wanted were already gone by the time I placed my order.
0
Reply
christa-Sinstack
April 08, 2026
"Took a Little Longer Than Expected"
I ordered from cigarchief and the processing time was a bit slower than I expected. The order didn’t ship out as quick as I thought it would, so I ended up waiting longer than planned. Everything do go through fine in the end, and the order itself was okay. I just wish they was a little faster with getting it processed.
0
Reply
richard.Woodard
April 01, 2026
"No surprise fees"
I liked that the shipping cost showed up before checkout, so there werent any random surprise fees at the end. Made ordering way easier thats all I really needed.
0
Reply
ChristineMetz_11
April 01, 2026
"I had to do the age verification…"
I had to do the age verification on cigarchief.com and it was simple. I just uploaded what they asked for, and it went through faster than I expected. No weird extra steps or anything like that. It’s just nice when a site doesn’t make this part annoying.
0
Reply
Christine.stahl
March 27, 2026
"Damaged item was replaced, but an apology would’ve been nice"
One of my items showed up damaged in the mail, which was frustrating. I sent cigarchief some pictures, and they did replace it fairly quickly, though it still took a few days. They handled the replacement fine overall, but i was expecting at least a simple apology for the hassle. 4 stars.
0
Reply
Lynda_murr71
March 19, 2026
"Arrived in great shape"
To be fair, I checked it over carefully because I’ve had things arrive damaged before, but this one was completely fine. No dents, scratches, or damage at all.
0
Reply
James_ferguson92
March 18, 2026
"Fast, Honest, and Hassle-Free"
Everything went smoothly—no issues at all. I paid, it was handled quickly, and that was that. it feels good dealing with something straightforward and fair, where people just do what they’re supposed to do
0
Reply
hello_tom524
March 15, 2026
"Fresh and in Great Shape"
Not gonna lie, I was really happy with how these arrived. Every cigar was fresh, with no cracks, dry spots, or anything that made me worry. Definitely a solid experience
0
Reply
robert_Huffman03
March 11, 2026
"Mostly Accurate, Just a Little Unclear"
Overall, the product info was accurate, but when my order arrived, a couple of the details weren’t quite as clear as I expected (nothing major, just a little confusing). It wasn’t a big deal, but I did think the description could have matched the item a bit better.
0
Reply
janet.Burdett
March 03, 2026
"I had a quick question about..."
I had a quick question about my order and they got back to me sooner than I expected. The answer was clear, and they were actually friendly about it too. As someone who gets a little frustrated when shops make simple things complicated, I really appreciated how easy they made it.
0
Reply
reynaldo.Torres
March 03, 2026
"They do carry some premium cigars, which is…"
They do carry some premium cigars, which is nice, but the selection feels a little inconsistent. A few good options are usually there, but the ones I’m actually looking for seem to be missing often. It’s not bad, just kind of frustrating if you’re expecting a reliable premium lineup.
0
Reply
gladys.Coles
February 24, 2026
"Duty fee was straightforward"
Duty was handled fine on my order, and I didn’t get hit with any weird extra charges. Smooth overall. Did anyone else have the same experience, or did you run into extra fees?
0
Reply
JuanitaHitchcock_18
February 14, 2026
"Pretty smooth experience, right?"
My orders showed up exactly as expected, the tracking worked the whole way, and there weren’t any weird issues or surprises. That’s really all you want when ordering, right? I’d definitely trust them again
0
Reply
FIRESTINE
February 14, 2026
"Good fix, but slower than expected"
They did end up fixing the issue, so I’ll give them credit for that. It just took a lot longer than I expected, especially compared to other places I’ve dealt with where things were handled a bit quicker.
0
Reply
glendapatterson3134
February 13, 2026
"Prices were better than my local shop"
I assumed it’d be about the same as my local place, but the prices were actually better. Super easy, no hassle, and I got what I needed without any fuss.
0
Reply
Have a question about Cigar Chief?
Log in to ask your Cigar Chief question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
